Much More to Come
We will be adding much more content to help you make the best financial decisions for your wedding day. 

5 carat heart shaped diamond ring Buying Guide

Save $26,352 with our handy guide.
In this guide, we will show you how to get the most out of your purchase of a heart-shaped diamond ring weighing 5 carats. We will explain when it's worth spending more and when you can cut back, and provide you with information on where to find your perfect ring or maybe even something even more exceptional.
Don't want to learn, just want to shop?
We have gathered the most affordable deals for 5-carat heart-shaped diamond rings from top online platforms. You can check out our carefully selected options in the linked section.

Diamond Price Guide Overview
8 buying lessons - 5-10 min total read time

Find the best bargain for a top-notch 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring.

In the upcoming lessons, we will guide you on acquiring the largest and most dazzling 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring without breaking the bank. We'll provide tips on maximizing your budget and help you steer clear of any deceitful practices by diamond companies.
Average Price
$77,400.00
Price Range
$60,930-$93,870
Our Max Savings
$26,352
Lessons 1-4  ∴  Save Money 
Lessons 4 & 5  ∶  Spend Money 
Lessons 6-8  ∴  Personalize & Decide 
⤫ 40% Cash Savings

Lesson 1

Buying Online

You can find better prices on diamond rings when you shop online. Retailers often inflate their prices by 40% and offer a limited selection to choose from.
$29,490 Cash Savings

Lesson 2

Clarity

By following our clarity tips, you can potentially reduce the cost of diamond rings by 50%. We are here to help you save significantly.
$20,360 Cash Savings

Lesson 3

Color

The color of a diamond plays a big role in determining its price. We are here to help you understand how to use this information to your advantage and save money.
⤫ 85% Cash Savings

Lesson 8

Lab Grown

You can save a significant 85% on a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring by opting for lab-grown alternatives. However, it may not be practical to resell it.
☺ Spend Money

Lesson 4

Carat Weight / Size

Since women tend to prefer diamonds that appear larger, it's wise to spend more of your budget on that aspect. We're here to assist you in maximizing the size while also saving money in other aspects.
☺ Spend Money

Lesson 5

Cut, Sparkle & Brilliance

The way a diamond is cut greatly impacts how it looks overall. It's not a good idea to skimp on this aspect because it's what really brings out the diamond's sparkle and stunning appearance.
≔ Personalize

Lesson 6

Shapes

The appearance of a diamond ring varies depending on its shape. We will walk you through the unique characteristics and sparkle of each shape.
≔ Personalize

Lesson 7

Setting / Band

Opting for a solitaire ring can help you save some cash and enhance the visibility of your diamond. However, it's important to consider that personal preferences also play a role in making this decision.

Lesson 1 - Buy Online
Up to 40% savings here

Get your 5-carat heart-shaped diamond ring online and you could save up to 40% instantly!

Shopping for jewelry online has many advantages compared to going to a physical store. One major benefit is the cost savings. Online platforms like Blue Nile and James Allen can sell diamonds at much lower prices, sometimes up to 40% cheaper, because they don't have the same expenses as traditional retailers. Another advantage of shopping online is the wide variety of options available. Websites offer a broader selection, making it easier to find the perfect diamond among a wide range of choices. Additionally, online platforms provide more customization options, allowing you to personalize your ring according to your specific vision. This not only adds value but also gives your jewelry a unique touch.

Click on one of the "shop now" links below to start creating a 5 carat heart-shaped diamond ring that is both affordable and of excellent quality!

If you're eager to begin shopping, our links will direct you to the best deals on high-quality diamonds from top-rated online diamond retailers.

Our Money Saving Links

Watch us compare pricing with retail stores and our favorite online brands

Ease of Use
Pricing
Selection
Customer Service
Best overall experience, great selection, 24/7 customer support
Ease of Use
Pricing
Selection
Customer Service
Another excellent website for very well priced diamond rings.
Ease of Use
Pricing
Selection
Customer Service
They focus on ethically sourced diamonds. Best option for karma free rings
Ease of Use
Pricing
Selection
Customer Service
They focus on ethically sourced diamonds. Best option for karma free rings
Ease of Use
Pricing
Selection
Customer Service
Mostly here to show you how retail companies are not high quality. 

Lesson 2 - Clarity

When shopping for a 0.5 carat cushion cut diamond ring, the clarity of the diamond is the most important aspect to keep in mind regarding its price.

⊗ Up to $25,857 savings with these tips
Watch us save thousands of dollars by simply selecting the right clarity range.

What is Clarity?

In the world of diamonds, clarity refers to how flawless they appear. However, it's important to note that the term "noticeable" is key here, as most imperfections can only be seen under a 10x magnifying glass. Diamond clarity is categorized from 'flawless' (FL) to 'included' (I), with classifications like VS1 (Very Slightly Included), VS2, and SI1 (Slightly Included) falling in between. Diamonds in these categories often have blemishes that can only be seen with a 10x magnifier. So, to the naked eye, they usually look completely clear, ensuring that anyone admiring your ring won't notice any flaws!

Optimal Clarity Range for a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring

Choosing a diamond in the VS2-SI1 clarity range for your 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring can result in significant savings, potentially reducing the total price by as much as $25,857. When considering the clarity options, we strongly suggest opting for VS2 due to its excellent balance between price and clarity. However, it is important not to disregard SI1 diamonds. By dedicating just a few minutes to carefully examining the diamonds, you can discover ones that possess an almost flawless appearance.

One more important tip! Always avoid "cloudy"

This one is simple. Always avoid cloudy diamonds found in the GIA certificate. This is the one flaw that really matters for brilliance. 
☆ These diamonds have identical carat, cut, & color 
Not Recommended
Go with this clarity
FL
IF
VVS1
VVS2
VS1
VS2
SI1
‹ drag left or right ›

FL - Flawless

Cost - $103,257 This diamond is absolutely flawless, without any imperfections at all. However, considering the cost, it's extremely expensive. Savings - You could save $38,872 - $29,727 with a VS2, SI1, or SI2 diamond
‹ drag left or right ›

IF - Internally Flawless

Cost - $93,870 This diamond is internally perfect, which means there are no flaws inside it, although there might be some on the surface. It's quite extravagant. Savings - You could save $29,485 - $20,340 with a VS2, SI1, or SI2 diamond
‹ drag left or right ›

VVS1

Cost - $89,177 This diamond is practically perfect, but considering its price, it's still excessively expensive. Savings - You could save $24,792 - $15,647 with a VS2, SI1, or SI2 diamond
‹ drag left or right ›

VVS2

Cost - $84,718 These diamonds are really impressive and the prices are more reasonable, but we still recommend choosing a diamond with a lower clarity. Savings - You could save $20,333 - $11,188 with a VS2, SI1, or SI2 diamond
‹ drag left or right ›

VS1 - Very Slightly Included

Cost - $67,774 If you come across an amazing deal on a VS1 diamond, that's really great. However, the upcoming clarity grades are known to offer the best combination of affordability and value. Savings - You could save $3,389 - $-5,756 with a VS2, SI1, or SI2 diamond

‹ drag left or right ›

VS2 - Very Slightly Included

Cost: $64,385 Total Savings: $3,389 - $29,485 These diamonds provide the highest quality and most affordable prices in terms of clarity. As an ordinary person, you won't be able to detect any flaws in the majority of these diamonds, making them appear perfect to your eyes.
‹ drag left or right ›

SI1 - Slightly Included

Cost: $77,400 Total Savings: $-9,626 - $16,470 This is the best option for diamond clarity at an incredibly affordable price. It's important to note that not all SI1 diamonds are the same. While some may not live up to your expectations, there are many that are absolutely stunning and could even be mistaken for a higher quality VS2 diamond.

Lesson 3 - Color

The color you choose for a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring greatly affects its price.

⊗ Up to $28,805 savings with these tips
Watch us save thousands by purchasing diamonds in the right range

What is Color?

Diamonds can come in a yellowish hue or have no color at all. The GIA categorizes them from D (no color) to Z (yellow or brown). Most diamonds used in jewelry have a slight color, falling within the G-H range. Only when compared to higher grade diamonds like D, E, or F, can you notice any faint color traces. Although color is more noticeable in larger diamonds, a heart diamond in the G-H range will look almost colorless and be less expensive than a D-grade diamond, which is colorless.

Optimal Color Range For A 5 Carat Heart Shaped Diamond Ring

When selecting a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring, opting for a color grade within the G-H range is recommended. By doing so, you can prevent any noticeable color contrast that may arise when comparing I-J graded diamonds to the smaller, typically colorless or near-colorless diamonds surrounding the main stone. This choice not only ensures a visually appealing design but also allows for potential savings of up to $28,805, in addition to any savings made by making informed decisions regarding clarity.
Clearest Color
Best Value
Sometimes Ok
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
< drag left or right >

D color

Cost - $92,880 This diamond is colorless, meaning it has no hints of yellow, you can find these at a good price, but it is not as common. Savings - You could save $15,735 - $20,364 with a G or H colored diamond
‹ drag left or right ›

E color

Cost - $87,307 An E color diamond is a rare, colorless gem of exceptional beauty and value. You can sometimes find them at a great price. Savings - You could save $10,163 - $14,791 with a G or H colored diamond
‹ drag left or right ›

F color

Cost - $82,069 These are near-colorless with only slight traces of color, making it an attractive choice. You'd really have to look closely to figure it out Savings - You could save $4,924 - $9,553 with a G or H colored diamond
‹ drag left or right ›

G color

Cost - $77,145 These are near-colorless with only slight traces of color, making it an attractive choice for it's quality and price. You'd really have to look closely to notice any color Savings - You could save $4,629 with an H colored diamond
‹ drag left or right ›

H color

Cost - $72,516 Total Savings: $4,629 - $20,364 These are near-colorless with only slightly more noticable hint of color, further making it an attractive choice for it's quality and price. You'd need to have a trained eye to see the color flaw in this one without having a colorless diamond next to it.
‹ drag left or right ›

I color

Cost - $68,165 Total Savings: $8,980 - $24,715 These begin to have a bit more noticable hint of color especially when next to colorless diamonds. These still have unnoticable color if placed on a solitaire ring, but we do not recommend these on a halo ring.
‹ drag left or right ›

J color

Cost - $64,075 Total Savings: $13,070 - $28,805 These also have a slightly more noticable hint of color especially when next to colorless diamonds. These still have unnoticable color if placed on a solitaire ring, but we do not recommend these on a halo ring.

Lab Grown Diamonds

Lab grown diamonds can often cut prices in half and no one will ever notice the difference. 

Lesson 4 - Lab Grown
Save up to 85% on your diamond ring.

Save over $70,000 on your 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring with lab grown diamonds.

Lab-grown diamonds are incredibly attractive because they look just like natural diamonds, even though they are made in a lab. What makes them even more appealing is that the way they are produced is environmentally friendly and morally responsible. On top of that, lab-grown diamonds are significantly more affordable than natural diamonds, with prices that can be up to 85% lower.

If you ever have to sell your 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring, choosing a lab-grown diamond can help mitigate your financial loss.

When selecting a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring, opting for a color grade within the G-H range is recommended. By doing so, you can prevent any noticeable color contrast that may arise when comparing I-J graded diamonds to the smaller, typically colorless or near-colorless diamonds surrounding the main stone. This choice not only ensures a visually appealing design but also allows for potential savings of up to $28,805, in addition to any savings made by making informed decisions regarding clarity.
Explore Lab Grown 

Lesson 5 - Carat / Size

Focus your money on carat weight when you are shopping for a diamond ring.

Why is Carat Important?

Take a moment to consider a diamond ring. The first thing that catches your eye is the size of the sparkling center diamond, isn't it? Well, for women, it's the same thing. They prioritize size above anything else. That's why when it comes to carat weight, which directly affects the size of the diamond, we suggest, "That's where you should allocate your budget!"
Watch us compare sizes and help you visualize what you want. 

Choose this Carat Range for your 5 carat heart-shaped diamond ring shopping.

You may want to consider looking at diamonds that range from 4.5 to 5.5 carats. This way, you can explore a variety of prices without a substantial increase in size.
Hand Diamond

1 carat

Explore More Diamond Weights

Lesson 6 - Cut

Always consider the cut of the diamond as it determines its sparkle. When buying your 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring, go for an ideal or excellent cut.

Find out why cut makes diamonds sparkle and why you want ideal or excellent cut diamonds.

What is Cut?

Looking for the most stunning heart-shaped diamond ring weighing 5 carats? The diamond's cut plays a vital role in its shine and radiance. It truly hinges on how flawlessly and precisely each of its facets is crafted.

A little-known secret within the world of diamonds.

You would think that an 'Ideal' cut diamond, which is perfectly proportioned to give you the most sparkle, would always be the most expensive. But the truth is, sometimes a 'Fair' cut diamond with the same carat, color, and clarity can actually cost more than an 'Ideal' cut. It might sound surprising, but here's why: a poorly cut diamond often appears larger, but it lacks the brilliance and sparkle that you're looking for. A diamond without sparkle is basically like a house without a solid foundation.

Here's a crucial tip: always opt for GIA Certified Excellent Cut Diamonds (also known as "Ideal" Cut).


Never Buy These
Definitely Buy These
Fair
Good
Very Good
Ideal
Excellent
‹ drag for sparkle ›

Fair Cut Diamond

Look at that dull sparkle... not much to write home about. Stay away from these.
‹ drag for sparkle ›

Good Cut

Still pretty bland in the sparkle area... stay away from these. 
‹ drag for sparkle ›

Very Good Cut

Getting better, but you don't save much money to  
‹ drag for sparkle ›

Ideal Cut

The is as low as you should go
‹ drag for sparkle ›

Excellent Cut

Blue Nile calls it Astor, James Allen calls it True Hearts, and Brilliant Earth calls it Truly Brilliant. 

Regardless, excellent cut diamonds have incredible sparkle.

Lesson 7 - Shape

When selecting diamonds, keep in mind that different shapes offer distinct levels of sparkle, and certain shapes can create the illusion of a pricier 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring.

What is Diamond Shape?

The shape of a diamond determines its unique style, whether it be round, oval, heart-shaped, or something else altogether. Different shapes can create optical illusions, making the diamond appear larger than it actually is. Additionally, certain shapes can enhance the diamond's brilliance and lend it a timeless elegance. Take a look at our shape tool in this section to explore a wide variety of 5 carat diamond rings with different shapes.

What shape to choose?

Sure, some diamond shapes can make the stone look bigger, and some shapes are popular right now. But remember, what really counts is what makes you the happiest. If you're not sure, a brilliant cut diamond, such as Round, Marquise, Princess, Cushion, Oval, Pear, and Radiant shapes, might be your best bet. Out of these, Round diamonds are the most popular, while Oval and Marquise shapes can give the impression of a larger diamond without weighing more.
Watch us compare shapes so you can see exactly what style you prefer. 

Explore other diamond shapes

Try out different diamonds

Hand Diamond
Round
Marquise
Princess
Emerald
Cushion
Oval
Pear
Asscher
Radiant
Heart

Lesson 8 - Setting

The band can completely transform the look of a 5 carat heart-shaped diamond ring.

What is setting?

The metal part of a diamond ring, which people commonly call the band, is actually called the setting. These settings are usually made of gold and come in different colors like white, yellow, or rose. You can also choose a platinum band if you prefer. The setting plays a huge role in how your 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring looks. It's a great way to show off your personal style. Here are the three most popular settings: 1. Prong setting: This setting uses metal claws or prongs to hold the diamond securely in place. It allows maximum light to enter the diamond, enhancing its brilliance and sparkle. 2. Bezel setting: In this setting, the metal completely surrounds the diamond, creating a more modern and sleek look. It offers excellent protection for the diamond and is a great choice for those who lead an active lifestyle. 3. Pave setting: This setting features small diamonds set closely together, creating a "paved" look. It adds extra sparkle to the ring and makes the center diamond appear even larger. Regardless of which setting you choose, we recommend sticking with 14k gold. We'll explain why this is the best option as you continue reading.
The setting or band is really important for making your diamond look bigger and better. 

Try to get a 14K gold band for your ring.

Always keep in mind this important advice. Avoid choosing 18k or 24k gold for your setting. Opt for 14k gold instead. Even though 18k and 24k gold are more pure, they are much softer and more prone to bending. If the setting that holds your precious diamond bends, there is a higher chance of the diamond coming loose and falling out. This is a problem that is commonly encountered.

Solitaire Choice - A Delicate Band Makes the Diamond Stand Out

As per surveys, the majority of women desire a significantly large diamond. A setting with a thin, delicate Solitaire band could accentuate the size of a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring. The juxtaposition of the small band with the large diamond creates an illusion of a more expansive stone. Small accent diamonds embedded in the band can further this illusion, adding a touch of elegance without detracting from the primary diamond.

Halo: Make Diamond Look Bigger with Lots of Smaller Diamonds

For a larger-looking 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring, give the halo setting a shot. This setting encircles the main diamond with smaller ones, giving off a bright and larger appearance. If you desire an even more impressive illusion, think about the double halo setting. Combined with a slim band, it can make even a small diamond seem much bigger, creating the impression of a more extravagant ring.

Maintain the Main Diamond's Dominance

A lot of ladies like their diamond to appear big. If your ring's band is too fancy or wide, it can shift attention away from the diamond and make it seem smaller. If you're mainly interested in the 5 carat heart-shaped diamond ring, a simpler band would be your best choice. However, if the overall design of the ring is what matters most to you, a more intricate band might be perfect. Just keep in mind that this could draw attention away from the diamond.

Build a Custom 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring Starting with Our Curated Diamond Selections For The Best Deals

Creating a customized piece of jewelry is a personal experience where you can design something that perfectly reflects your individual style and character. Not only does it provide the opportunity to tailor every aspect of your ring, from the diamond's shape to the band's design, but it also offers significant cost savings compared to buying from traditional stores. Trusted brands like Brilliant Earth, James Allen, and Blue Nile are leading the industry in providing these personalized options.
Start Building
Watch us take you through the entire building process on our favorite websites.

Shop online with one of our respected partners to make your purchase. Each link will take you to the top deal for a diamond ring.

We've collaborated with all the brands, and each Shop Now link is set up to find you the best price for the highest quality diamonds. To put it simply, it provides you with our exact settings on each website to discover the best deals for your needs. Take advantage of a wide selection, personalized rings, and exceptional customer support.

Our Money Saving Links

Watch us compare pricing with retail stores and our favorite online brands

Ease of Use
Pricing
Selection
Customer Service
Best overall experience, great selection, 24/7 customer support
Ease of Use
Pricing
Selection
Customer Service
Another excellent website for very well priced diamond rings.
Ease of Use
Pricing
Selection
Customer Service
They focus on ethically sourced diamonds. Best option for karma free rings
Ease of Use
Pricing
Selection
Customer Service
They focus on ethically sourced diamonds. Best option for karma free rings
Ease of Use
Pricing
Selection
Customer Service
Mostly here to show you how retail companies are not high quality. 

Virtual Appointment

Let us help you get help by the industry leaders. When you click the button below we will help you choose where to set up your appointment.
Book Appointment

Frequently Asked

Did you want to know even more? Wow you're a great student!

How much is a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring worth?

A 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring is worth an average price of $77,400. The price range for such a ring is between $60,930 and $93,870.

How big is a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring?

A 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring has a width of 10.5mm and a length of 11mm. In comparison, a 4.5 carat heart shaped diamond ring would have a slightly smaller width of 10mm and a length of 10.5mm. On the other hand, a 5.5 carat heart shaped diamond ring would have a slightly larger width of 11mm and a length of 11.5mm.

What does a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring look like like on a hand?

What is the price of a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring?

The price of a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring falls within the price range of $60,930-$93,870.

Is a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring good enough?

Yes, a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring can be considered good enough. Heart shaped diamonds are known for their romantic and unique appeal. The larger carat weight adds to the overall impact and presence of the ring, making it an impressive choice. However, it is important to consider other factors such as the cut, clarity, and craftsmanship to ensure the diamond is of high quality and visually appealing.

Is a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring big?

Yes, a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring is considered big. The average carat weight for a diamond engagement ring is about 1.2 carats, so a 5 carat diamond is significantly larger. A 5 carat heart shaped diamond is quite noticeable and eye-catching due to its larger size and unique shape. It is considered a substantial and impressive piece of jewelry.

What does a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring weigh?

A 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring weighs 1 grams.

Should I get a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring?

A 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring would be an exquisite choice, as it combines the elegance of a heart shape with the impressive size of a 5 carat diamond.

Is a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring too big?

A 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring is considered large, but it ultimately depends on personal preference and style.

Is a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring small?

No, a 5 carat heart shaped diamond ring is not considered small. The carat weight of a diamond determines its size, and a 5 carat diamond is generally considered to be quite large. However, it's important to note that the appearance of the diamond can vary depending on the shape and setting of the ring.
Diamond Rotate
LazyLoad Youtube Video
LazyLoad Diamond Video
crossarrow-down-circle